Gamer/Law’s ten 2012 predictions

You’ve guessed it: I thought I’d jump into the it’s-a-new-year-let’s-make-some-predictions business for 2012.  And, like all forward-looking predictions, I’ve mixed a few safe bets with some slightly more “punchy” predictions (which FYI is lawyer-speak for taking a massive bet on something!)  Here goes, in no particular order:
(1) At least one celebrity will win substantial damages against a publisher
Consider the field.  Back in 2008/2009 a whole bunch of US football players won about $28m in damages from EA over their unauthorised appearance in John Madden football games (reduced on appeal) and there’s still other celebrities either considering or taking legal action over their appearance in sports games – including an ongoing class action lawsuit brought by former college atheletesAxl Rose is suing Activision over Slash’s appearance in Guitar Hero.   No Doubt are also suing Activision over their appearance in Guitar Hero.  A Cypress Hill rapper sued Take Two over his alleged unauthorised appearance in a Grand Theft auto game.   Lady GaGa sued Mind Candy over their release of a song by Moshi Monsters character Lady GooGoo.
The games industry is realising the power of brands, especially celebrity brands.  Celebrities are realising the power of games as a revenue generator and promotional tool.  Sooner or later, this is going to lead to a big problem.  The examples above are largely near misses or still-brewing problems: I think one of them, or another like them, is going to lead to a serious collision in 2012.
(2) The Infinity Ward lawsuit will go to trial and be ENORMOUS.
Read this interview with me here for details.  The trial will likely take place sometime around mid-late 2012 I’d guess – assuming it doesn’t settle first.  My totally speculative bet is that, given the amounts and issues at stake, it really should settle – but it won’t, because of the personalities and personal comments that have become involved.  Then again, as I’ve said many times before, lawsuits are a real rollercoaster so who knows what will happen…
(3) The legality and ethics of free to play will be a big issue in 2011.
I’ve been influenced by my friend Nicholas Lovell of Gamesbrief on this issue – read his post here.  I’m going to be speaking and writing about this a fair deal more in 2012, so watch this space.  In the meantime though, the short version is: the more that f2p focuses on influence/compulsion mechanics to get player to cough up dosh, the greater the legal and ethical risks it can raise – including the potential for regulators to start getting involved.  Stories like a UK child running up £900 in debt on Farmville for his mum  or a US child running up $1400 on Smurfville don’t really help.
(4) There will be more class action lawsuits…and no one will care.
There have been lots of class action lawsuits over the last 2 years or so in the games industry.  There was the Madden lawsuit I mentioned earlier (and there’s other class action lawsuits over Madden ongoing atm too).  There was the Other OS class action lawsuit (since dismissed in Sony’s favour).  There has since been another class action lawsuit against Sony following the fallout from the PSN outage this year.  There were class action lawsuit over Facebook and Zynga over privacy issues.  And so forth.
This is what they all had in common: no one really cared, apart from the defendants of the lawsuits.  This is a shame: whether you agree with these class action lawsuits or not, they’ve clearly had an impact on a wide number of players in the games industry and it’s a pity there hasn’t been more attention drawn to them (both to those lawsuits which raise legitimate grievances as well as to those which are just money-grabbing).  So, I wanted to use this prediction to both show that there will be more such lawsuits in the industry in 2012 – and that most people will ignore them.
(5) Data privacy will continue quietly to become one of the biggest issues in the games industry…and again no-one will care.
People are really motivated by data privacy protection.  We’ve seen that with the problems encountered by the search engines and social networks regarding their use of data harvested from their users – Facebook above all.  The modern games industry, especially mobile and social games, is built on constant data collection.  With a few honourable exceptions, the majority of the games industry doesn’t care a great deal about protecting that data.  This is going to be a problem.
In fact, it’s already a problem, but it’s going largely undetected in public so far.  Behind the scenes, savvy games developers and publishers will be looking at how they use and protect user data in 2012, but the majority won’t.  At some point, this is going to blow up – possibly worse than it did for the search engines/social networks.
(6) Virtual goods will creep towards full legal status, but won’t get it (yet).
In 2011, a man was successfully criminally prosecuted in the UK for effectively stealing virtual goods.  This involved recognising that virtual goods are property (I called it at the time the “first virtual goods crime”).  Similarly, in a lawsuit in Holland a court was invited to accept that virtual goods are property and therefore capable of being owned by players.
As this blog has argued previously (see here and here for example), there is a real issue over whether virtual goods should be considered goods (i.e. property) or just services: Gamer/Law’s views are that they are at least capable of being property, which would have huge implications for how virtual goods are treated in games at the moment.  The examples given above are good indications that this question is slowly being answered: I expect to see more of this in 2012, but we’re still some distance from any kind of authoritative answer.
(7) Multiple developers (possibly even publishers) will go into insolvency – leading to a renewed focus on insolvency law.
There was a lot going on in the developer world in 2011.  Several developers told me they expected life to be hard in 2012 and that some of their competitors would not make it.  I agree, sadly.   Hard economic times, aa lack of games funding, developers focusing on the wrong kinds of games and the sheer amount of competition all mean that times are going to get tougher for developers next year.  Publishers aren’t immune either: there are several mid-level publishers who are already in trouble.
As a result, my rather sombre and sad prediction is that we’ll see more insolvencies and layoffs from developers and possibly even publishers in 2012.  As a result, there will be renewed interest in legal matters arising from a company going under, not paying its employee or its debts and what happens to its valuable assets (like its IP). On the plus side, I’d also expect to see a number of new studios arising out of their ashes, as has happened over the past couple of years.
(8) Indies will both cooperate and fight more with each other.
The market pressures I outlined above will also weigh heavily on developers who have the stamina to keep trading.  As a result, I’m already seeing a whole range of different moves by indies to collaborate more with each other, from networking events to formal joint ventures.  Equally, I’m beginning to see a rise in developers having legal fights with each other, either because the collaboration didn’t work out or because of freestanding issues like IP infringement.  Expect more in 2012 – possibly even some high profile lawsuits between the new generation of successful developers.
(9) Games industry unionisation won’t happen…again.
Remember all that furore over the working conditions at Team Bondi and the various recriminations over it?  There was various talk about whether developers should have a representative body to defend them in these situations – effectively, a union.  Well, nothing happened.  Nor has anything happened really with previous problems of this kind – check out for example this BBC article back in 2006.
So why is this worth a prediction?  Because actually I think there’s something to be said for a representative body of that kind – whether it be an actual union or different national bodies (like TIGA or UKIE in the UK) taking on some of those responsibilities.  Excessive crunch and other unsatisfactory working practices clearly do go on in the games industry, and a body with collective bargaining powers would be useful in bringing them to an end.  But, for various reasons, nothing has happened so far in the games industry despite it being fundamentally similar to the film or music industries (both of which ofc are heavily unionised).  Answers on a postcard why that’s the case and whether/when that might change…
(10)  The high point of pro-film/music film IP laws will pass…but the games industry won’t be involved.
It’s fair to say that the majority of changes to IP law over the last decade have been far more influenced by the music and film industries than any of the other creative industries – including the games industry.  This is ofc despite the sharp rise in the games industry’s size and profile relative to music and film over the last few years.  This is a shame: the games industry has just as much to gain from a well-crafted set of IP laws worldwide as music and film do.  But it just hasn’t got its act together.
In the meantime, I’m predicting that history will show (heh, what a pretentious phrase) that 2011 was the high point of pro-music/film IP laws (by which I mean IP laws which focus more upon protecting the interests of large IP rights holders rather than consumers or small IP rights holders) and 2012 was the beginning of a move towards a more balanced approach.  For example, in the UK 2012 will mark the quiet shelfing of large portions of the aims of the Digital Economy Act 2010 and (hopefully) its replacement with a more sensible evidence-led approach (see my friend Jonny Mayner’s summary of the latest proposals following the UK Hargreaves Review here).  In the USA, I’m (maybe rather boldly) predicting that the likes of SOPA will either be watered down or lawmakers will finally become aware that the majority of consumers don’t actually want laws like them.  It’s just a shame the games industry had  nothing to do with these changes.
So those are my ten predictions for 2012.  Let’s see how right, or terribly wrong, I will be this time next year…
Follow us at http://www.twitter.com/gamerlaw or subscribe to our email updates here

16 comments

  1. Hi How do you feel about the lack of safety advice on video games, in the UK the UKIE website carries some advice but the information is not actually on the products for gamers to see ?? check out http://www.take-time-out.info to learn about the campaign we are pressing for – we see this as a major worldwide issue for the gaming industry.
    Thank You

  2. I'm so excited for these things to happen this 2012. Anxious though since some things are not that good.

  3. A lot of thanks for your entire work on this site. My niece really loves setting aside time for internet research and it is obvious why. Most people know all regarding the compelling mode you create both useful and interesting suggestions on the web site and strongly encourage contribution from other people on the theme plus our girl is now becoming educated so much. Enjoy the remaining portion of the year. You’re carrying out a good job.

  4. I am also commenting to make you know what a incredible discovery my daughter undergone browsing your web page. She discovered several things, which include how it is like to have a marvelous helping mood to let folks without difficulty learn about chosen very confusing things. You actually did more than visitors’ expected results. Many thanks for producing those invaluable, trustworthy, revealing and cool guidance on that topic to Mary.

  5. I am only writing to make you understand what a outstanding discovery my friend’s girl gained checking the blog. She learned several things, with the inclusion of what it is like to have a very effective teaching mindset to make men and women without problems completely grasp specific tricky subject matter. You truly exceeded our own expected results. Thanks for coming up with such warm and helpful, trusted, informative and in addition fun tips on that topic to Gloria.

  6. I’m just writing to let you be aware of what a useful discovery our girl undergone reading through the blog. She learned so many pieces, most notably how it is like to possess an excellent teaching style to let most people clearly grasp specified complicated matters. You truly did more than visitors’ desires. Many thanks for rendering the essential, trustworthy, educational and unique thoughts on the topic to Emily.

  7. Thank you a lot for giving everyone an exceptionally terrific opportunity to read critical reviews from this blog. It is usually so kind and packed with a great time for me personally and my office co-workers to visit your web site on the least thrice in 7 days to see the newest tips you will have. And indeed, I am just usually amazed with the effective solutions you give. Selected 2 tips in this article are certainly the best we’ve had.

  8. Thank you so much for giving everyone remarkably memorable possiblity to read articles and blog posts from here. It is always very ideal and as well , stuffed with a lot of fun for me and my office friends to visit your web site at the very least 3 times in one week to read the latest issues you have got. Not to mention, I’m also actually contented concerning the good concepts served by you. Selected 1 facts in this post are clearly the most beneficial I have had.

  9. I’m just commenting to make you be aware of of the fabulous experience our child had viewing yuor web blog. She came to find many issues, with the inclusion of how it is like to have an incredible coaching heart to make the rest effortlessly learn chosen complicated issues. You truly did more than her expectations. Thanks for rendering the great, trusted, informative and in addition cool tips on this topic to Evelyn.

  10. My wife and i ended up being quite lucky Edward managed to finish off his studies while using the ideas he gained out of the web page. It is now and again perplexing to simply possibly be giving for free steps many others might have been making money from. We really remember we now have the website owner to thank for this. Those explanations you’ve made, the easy site menu, the friendships your site make it possible to foster – it is many great, and it’s really letting our son and our family understand the matter is thrilling, which is certainly tremendously pressing. Thank you for all the pieces!

  11. My wife and i were peaceful John could complete his investigation because of the precious recommendations he made through your site. It’s not at all simplistic to just happen to be handing out thoughts which often most people have been selling. We take into account we’ve got the website owner to give thanks to for this. The entire explanations you have made, the easy website navigation, the relationships you will help promote – it’s most remarkable, and it’s making our son in addition to us do think this content is brilliant, and that is rather fundamental. Thanks for the whole lot!

  12. A lot of thanks for all your hard work on this site. Ellie take interest in working on internet research and it is easy to understand why. Many of us know all relating to the dynamic form you make valuable tips via the website and encourage response from the others on the subject matter while my simple princess is understanding a great deal. Have fun with the rest of the year. Your carrying out a glorious job.

  13. My wife and i ended up being quite joyful Michael could do his survey with the ideas he received from your own web page. It is now and again perplexing to simply always be giving out instructions some people may have been trying to sell. Therefore we know we’ve got the website owner to give thanks to because of that. The main explanations you made, the simple site menu, the friendships you can give support to instill – it is everything sensational, and it is leading our son in addition to the family believe that the concept is thrilling, which is certainly quite important. Many thanks for the whole lot!

  14. I wish to get across my appreciation for your kindness for folks that have the need for assistance with this important situation. Your personal dedication to getting the solution all around appears to be extraordinarily interesting and have truly made women like me to arrive at their targets. Your interesting report implies a great deal to me and somewhat more to my office colleagues. With thanks; from each one of us.

  15. I am glad for commenting to make you understand of the really good encounter my friend’s child encountered visiting your site. She noticed many details, not to mention how it is like to have an awesome coaching mindset to get most people smoothly know certain tricky topics. You truly did more than visitors’ expectations. Thanks for displaying the powerful, trustworthy, revealing and also fun thoughts on that topic to Lizeth.

  16. Thanks for each of your hard work on this web page. My niece delights in engaging in internet research and it is simple to grasp why. All of us hear all about the lively form you provide useful steps by means of your web site and as well strongly encourage participation from other ones on the matter then our princess has always been being taught a lot. Enjoy the rest of the year. You have been doing a dazzling job.

Comments are closed.