Celebrities, attack!

Activision releases Band Hero and, very soon after, the rock band No Doubt sue Activision for unauthorised use of the band in the game amounting allegedly to the band being turned into a “virtual karaoke circus act“.  Before that, Courtney Love kicks up a stink about the use of Kurt Cobain in Guitar Hero 5.  This, ladies and gentlemen, is what happens when celebrities go bad

First up, what is No Doubt’s beef?  According to a LA Times article (courtesy of Game Politics), No Doubt had an agreement with Activision pursuant to which the band would feature in Band Hero singing their own songs.  However, Activision allegedly went far beyond that and the game allows other artists to play No Doubt songs and for No Doubt avatars to sing other artists’ songs.  Cue shock, anger, disgust from No Doubt + 1 lawsuit alleging breach of contract and No Doubt’s right to publicity. 

Activision’s response: they said, reasonably enough, that they had negotiated a detailed agreement with No Doubt regarding the use of the band in the game and that they believed that they were within their contractual rights.  Which basically means that the dispute seems likely to boil down to a matter of interpretation of the contract: either Activision is right or No Doubt is.

Courtney Love gets angry…again

Move on to example # 2 – Courtney Love jumping on the Angry Train re the appearance of Kurt Cobain as an avatar in Guitar Hero 5.  As with Band Hero, the Cobain avatar can be used to play Nirvana songs as well as songs from other artists.  Love (and, to a lesser extent, Nirvana bandmembers) argued that Activision should not have used Cobain’s image at all and threatened a lawsuit to block its use in the game. 

Activision’s response, again, was that it had entered into a detailed agreement with Cobain’s estate for the use of a Cobain avatar in the game.  So, once again, it comes down to a matter of contractual interpretation.


Both disputes would of course have to be decided ultimately by applicable US contract and IP law. That said, a few immediate thoughts are:

(i) In both cases, money seems the prime motivation.  But could No Doubt and the Cobain estate really show they have suffered substantial loss? (Certainly from a UK perspective anyway.)  Has it really hurt their image/materially infringed their rights for other avatars to sing their songs or vice versa?  Of course, it may not just be about financial loss – an equally effective remedy would be to obtain a Court order pulling the game altogether (which would no doubt bring Activision running to the settlement table).

(ii) This really does show, again, the importance of making sure your contracts are as clear as they can be and – crucially – that both parties have the same understanding as to what they are both giving and receiving.  Of course, it’s always possible that No Doubt/Courtney Love know exactly what rights they gave to Activision but are having a go anyway in order to extract a quick cash settlement – but that always runs the risk of Activision’s lawyers advising it to fight them all the way…
(iii) Have No Doubt/the Cobain estate really thought about PR?  It’s all very well standing on your legal rights, but part of our standard advice to clients before they push the litigation button is always that they should think very carefully about the implications that litigation could have on their standing with their customers and in the market more generally.  On the other hand, if Activision are in the wrong here then maybe they should have expected that at least one artist, at some point, was going to raise these issues.  That might well be something for all publishers to think on, what with the current trend towards introducing celebities into games…

As always, we’ll be keeping an eye on this one…

[image source: Wikipedia]

14 thoughts on “Celebrities, attack!”

  1. A lot of thanks for all of your hard work on this blog. Kim delights in carrying out research and it is easy to see why. We notice all concerning the powerful way you render simple things via your blog and as well as cause participation from other people on the concern then our child is starting to learn a great deal. Enjoy the remaining portion of the new year. Your carrying out a fabulous job.

  2. I definitely wanted to develop a small remark in order to say thanks to you for all of the magnificent recommendations you are sharing on this website. My extended internet search has at the end of the day been paid with high-quality suggestions to write about with my partners. I ‘d claim that many of us visitors actually are undeniably endowed to live in a good website with very many awesome professionals with insightful principles. I feel pretty happy to have discovered the webpages and look forward to tons of more brilliant times reading here. Thanks a lot once more for everything.

  3. I together with my guys came examining the great hints found on your site and then suddenly I got a horrible suspicion I never expressed respect to the web blog owner for those strategies. All the guys are already as a result warmed to learn all of them and have in effect without a doubt been having fun with them. I appreciate you for indeed being quite considerate and then for making a choice on this form of high-quality things millions of individuals are really desirous to understand about. Our own sincere apologies for not saying thanks to you sooner.

  4. I really wanted to jot down a brief comment in order to express gratitude to you for all of the splendid hints you are sharing at this site. My time intensive internet investigation has now been paid with good quality details to go over with my colleagues. I would tell you that many of us visitors actually are very much endowed to dwell in a decent network with so many lovely individuals with very beneficial points. I feel quite lucky to have seen the site and look forward to so many more fun moments reading here. Thanks again for everything.

  5. I needed to create you a very small observation to help give many thanks over again for your lovely tactics you have shown on this website. It is quite incredibly generous with people like you to present extensively all that numerous people could possibly have advertised for an ebook to help make some bucks for themselves, and in particular since you might have done it if you ever wanted. Those points also served as the easy way to fully grasp that some people have the identical zeal really like my very own to understand great deal more related to this condition. Certainly there are lots of more fun sessions up front for those who read your website.

  6. I enjoy you because of each of your work on this website. Ellie enjoys engaging in investigation and it is easy to see why. My partner and i hear all relating to the lively medium you present advantageous items on this blog and as well strongly encourage participation from other ones on that concept so our favorite girl has been becoming educated a lot of things. Have fun with the rest of the new year. You are always carrying out a fabulous job.

  7. Needed to create you this bit of note in order to say thanks a lot as before just for the great concepts you have documented on this page. It’s quite strangely generous with people like you to present publicly all a few people could have supplied as an electronic book in order to make some dough for themselves, principally seeing that you could have tried it in case you considered necessary. The tricks additionally acted as a good way to know that the rest have similar zeal just as my very own to see way more when considering this problem. I’m sure there are several more fun moments ahead for people who look into your site.

  8. I not to mention my buddies have been examining the good thoughts located on your web site and so before long came up with a horrible feeling I never expressed respect to the website owner for them. The people were definitely for that reason very interested to see all of them and have in effect extremely been enjoying those things. Many thanks for getting very considerate as well as for finding variety of good tips most people are really wanting to understand about. My personal sincere regret for not expressing gratitude to sooner.

  9. I have to show my appreciation to you just for bailing me out of this type of matter. Right after looking throughout the world-wide-web and seeing concepts that were not beneficial, I thought my life was gone. Existing devoid of the solutions to the difficulties you have resolved by way of your entire posting is a critical case, and those which might have in a negative way affected my career if I hadn’t come across your web site. Your good understanding and kindness in controlling a lot of stuff was tremendous. I don’t know what I would’ve done if I had not encountered such a thing like this. I’m able to at this time relish my future. Thanks very much for your skilled and sensible guide. I won’t be reluctant to endorse the sites to any individual who ought to have tips on this subject.

  10. I needed to write you that little bit of word to finally say thanks again over the gorgeous knowledge you’ve provided here. It’s so strangely open-handed with people like you giving freely exactly what some people might have offered for sale for an ebook to end up making some bucks for themselves, precisely given that you could have tried it in the event you decided. The principles additionally served to become fantastic way to be certain that some people have the identical interest really like my own to know the truth great deal more with regard to this issue. I’m certain there are many more pleasurable opportunities ahead for people who discover your blog post.

  11. My husband and i have been joyful Emmanuel managed to deal with his investigation by way of the precious recommendations he grabbed through the web pages. It’s not at all simplistic to simply always be making a gift of information and facts that many men and women might have been making money from. Therefore we consider we need you to give thanks to for this. The main explanations you have made, the straightforward blog navigation, the relationships you can aid to foster – it’s mostly fantastic, and it is letting our son in addition to the family understand the content is pleasurable, which is pretty vital. Thank you for all!

  12. My spouse and i felt really fortunate that Emmanuel could carry out his reports while using the precious recommendations he made out of the web page. It is now and again perplexing just to happen to be giving away instructions which often a number of people have been trying to sell. So we grasp we have got the blog owner to thank for that. The main explanations you’ve made, the straightforward website navigation, the relationships you make it easier to promote – it is many fabulous, and it’s really making our son and us understand this matter is cool, which is exceptionally fundamental. Thanks for everything!

  13. I really wanted to jot down a note so as to say thanks to you for the fabulous tips you are placing on this site. My considerable internet lookup has finally been paid with wonderful facts and techniques to share with my co-workers. I would declare that most of us readers actually are extremely endowed to live in a really good place with very many marvellous professionals with useful tactics. I feel very much blessed to have come across your website page and look forward to really more exciting minutes reading here. Thank you again for all the details.

  14. I would like to voice my admiration for your kindness supporting persons that require assistance with this particular concept. Your very own dedication to getting the message along was pretty good and has surely allowed individuals just like me to get to their aims. This invaluable guide means a lot a person like me and substantially more to my peers. Best wishes; from each one of us.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *